Services are FREE for anyone who has Title XIX Medicaid or SoonerCare in Oklahoma

918-960-7852

5 Questions Every Therapy Client Should Ask Before Starting Treatment

Posted by Improving Lives Counseling Services, Inc. | Articles, Counseling, Mental Health

Introduction

Starting therapy is one of the most courageous decisions you can make for your mental health. But walking into your first session without asking the right questions is a little like starting a road trip without a map. You might get somewhere, but it may not be where you intended to go.

Here is the reality: Research shows that between 20% and 57% of therapy clients do not return after their very first session, and another 37–45% attend only twice. One of the biggest drivers of early dropout is mismatched expectations, poor therapist fit, and unanswered questions about what therapy actually involves.

The good news is that asking the right questions upfront dramatically increases your chances of a successful experience. According to the American Psychological Association, about 75% of people who engage in therapy see positive results. That success is far more likely when you enter treatment informed, empowered, and with a therapist who genuinely fits your needs.

This guide walks you through the five most important questions every therapy client should ask before starting treatment. Whether you are seeking help for anxiety, depression, relationship challenges, trauma, or life transitions, these questions will help you find the right therapist, understand what to expect, and make the most of every session.

At Improving Lives Counseling Services(ILCS), serving Tulsa, Broken Arrow, Oklahoma City, Tahlequah, Pryor, Stillwater, and communities throughout Oklahoma, our team welcomes these conversations. We believe an informed client is an empowered client.

Why Asking Questions Before Therapy Matters

Many people approach their first therapy appointment the same way they approach a medical appointment. They answer questions but rarely ask them. This dynamic, while understandable, can actually undermine the effectiveness of treatment before it even begins.

Therapy is fundamentally different from most healthcare encounters. It is a collaborative process built on what researchers call the therapeutic alliance, the working relationship between you and your therapist. A 2024 review published in Frontiers in Psychology confirmed that the therapeutic alliance is a robust predictor of treatment outcomes across all types of psychotherapy, meaning the quality of your relationship with your therapist matters as much as the specific techniques they use.

Asking questions helps you:

  • Gauge whether a therapist is the right fit before investing significant time and money
  • Set realistic expectations about what therapy can and cannot do
  • Understand what your treatment will look like day to day
  • Clarify logistical concerns that, if unaddressed, may cause you to drop out
  • Establish a foundation of open communication from the very first session

Think of these questions as an investment in your own treatment. A good therapist will not only welcome them but will see them as a sign that you are serious about doing the work.

The State of Mental Health Treatment in America and Oklahoma

Before diving into the questions themselves, it is worth understanding the landscape you are entering.

According to the CDC’s most recent 2024 data, about 1 in 7 U.S. adults received counseling or therapy from a mental health professional in the past 12 months, a figure higher than the year before. Therapists across the U.S. report that 68% are seeing a rise in first-time therapy seekers, and 78% say their patients begin to see results within the early stages of treatment.

Yet despite this growing openness to therapy, more than half of adults with a mental illness still receive no treatment at all. In Oklahoma, where mental health resources can vary significantly across rural and urban communities, access to quality, affordable care remains a genuine challenge for many families.

The gap between those who need help and those who receive it has many causes, including stigma, cost, logistical barriers, and not knowing what to look for in a therapist.

The five questions below directly address that last barrier.

Question 1: What Are Your Credentials, and Are You Licensed to Practice in Oklahoma?

This is the first and most foundational question, and the one most people are too polite to ask. Do not be.

Why This Question Matters

Licensing is not a bureaucratic formality. It is your primary protection as a client. In Oklahoma, the State Board of Behavioral Health Licensure (BBHL) governs the practice of Licensed Professional Counselors (LPCs), Licensed Marital and Family Therapists (LMFTs), and Licensed Behavioral Practitioners (LBPs). The Oklahoma State Board of Licensed Social Workers governs Licensed Clinical Social Workers (LCSWs).

As Psychology Today notes, you should not see a therapist who is not licensed. A certification in a type of therapy is not the same as a state license. A license means the provider has completed:

  • A qualifying graduate degree (master’s level or higher)
  • Thousands of hours of supervised clinical experience
  • A state or national licensing examination
  • Ongoing continuing education requirements

Understanding the Credential Alphabet Soup

When you look at a therapist’s profile, you will often see a string of letters after their name. Here is a quick guide to the most common credentials:

  • LPC (Licensed Professional Counselor): Trained primarily in counseling and psychotherapy, treating mental health conditions such as depression, anxiety, and trauma. In Oklahoma, LPCs must complete 3,000 hours of supervised experience.
  • LCSW (Licensed Clinical Social Worker): Holds a master’s in social work with training in psychotherapy and a systems-based approach that considers social and environmental factors affecting mental health.
  • LMFT (Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist): Specializes in relationships, family dynamics, and systems-based care, and is also fully qualified to work with individuals.

As experts note, all three credential types are widely recognized by insurance companies and can provide effective care. The key difference lies in their training emphasis and philosophical approach.

At ILCS, you can explore the backgrounds and credentials of our clinical team directly on our staff page. Every therapist on our roster is fully licensed in the state of Oklahoma.

What to Ask

  • “Are you licensed in Oklahoma, and what type of license do you hold?”
  • “How long have you been practicing, and are you currently under supervision?”
  • “Can you tell me about your educational background?”

A good therapist will answer these questions clearly and without defensiveness.

Question 2: Do You Have Experience Treating My Specific Concerns?

Therapy is not a one-size-fits-all service, and not every therapist is equipped to treat every condition. This question is about more than credentials. It is about real-world expertise.

Why This Question Matters

Not all therapists are trained to treat all issues, as Psychology Today points out plainly. A therapist who specializes in substance use disorders may not be the best fit for someone navigating grief or postpartum anxiety. A couples counselor may have limited experience with childhood trauma. Specialty matters.

Research published in Counselling and Psychotherapy Research in 2024 found that clients are more likely to drop out of therapy when the treatment type is not aligned with their preference or presenting concern. Misalignment in this area does not just waste time. It can leave you feeling like “therapy doesn’t work for me” when in reality, the issue was simply a wrong match.

What to Ask

  • “How much experience do you have treating [anxiety / depression / trauma / relationship issues]?”
  • “What therapeutic approaches do you specialize in, and why do you think they might work for my concerns?”
  • “Have you successfully helped other clients with similar challenges to mine?”

Question 3: What Can I Realistically Expect from Treatment, and How Long Will It Take?

This is the question most people want to ask but feel they should not. Ask it anyway. Unrealistic expectations are a major driver of early therapy dropout, and a good therapist will give you an honest answer.

Why This Question Matters

Many people walk into their first therapy appointment hoping to feel better within a session or two. While some clients do experience early relief, meaningful and lasting change typically takes more time. The actual timeline depends heavily on your specific concerns, goals, history, and your commitment to the process. Some people benefit significantly from a relatively brief course of therapy. Others, particularly those working through chronic conditions or complex trauma, may need ongoing support over a longer period.

Research consistently shows that the best predictor of how long therapy will take is the nature of what brings you in, not a fixed number of sessions. A skilled therapist will discuss this with you openly and revisit the conversation as your treatment progresses.

That uncertainty is not meant to discourage you. It is meant to help you approach the process with patience and realistic expectations, which is one of the most important factors in whether therapy ultimately works.

What Progress Looks Like

Progress in therapy does not always look the way people expect. Many clients notice:

  • A better understanding of their patterns and triggers in the early stages
  • Improved ability to identify unhelpful thoughts before acting on them
  • Gradually reduced intensity of symptoms over time
  • New coping skills that start to feel more natural
  • Improved relationships and communication

Improvement is rarely linear. You may feel worse before you feel better, particularly as you begin to process difficult experiences. This is not a sign that therapy is not working. It is often a sign that it is.

What to Ask

  • “Given what I have shared, what are realistic expectations for my treatment?”
  • “How will we measure progress? What would success look like in a few months?”
  • “How long do you typically work with clients dealing with concerns like mine?”
  • “What happens if I am not seeing progress? Will you adjust the approach?”

Understanding the expected arc of treatment helps you stay the course when things feel hard, and hard periods in therapy are often where the most growth happens.

Question 4: What Does Treatment Actually Look Like, and What Will Be Expected of Me?

Therapy is not something that happens to you. It is something you do, actively and consistently, with professional support. Understanding your role in the process is essential before you begin.

Why This Question Matters

One of the most common reasons people drop out of therapy early is surprise, either about how much work is involved, how sessions are structured, or what happens between appointments. A meta-analysis cited by Therapist Aid found that about 1 in 5 patients leave treatment before reaching an acceptable level of recovery, often because of unaddressed expectations.

When you understand what the work actually looks like, you can show up prepared, engaged, and with the right mindset.

The Structure of a Typical Session

Most therapy sessions follow a consistent structure, though the format and length can vary depending on the type of therapy and your individual treatment plan. Your therapist will walk you through what to expect at the start of treatment.Session length can vary based on the type of therapy being used. Trauma-focused approaches like EMDR or Cognitive Processing Therapy often require extended sessions.

A typical session includes:

  • Check-in: How have you been since the last session? Any notable experiences or changes?
  • Core work: Exploring thoughts, feelings, patterns, or specific issues using your therapist’s chosen approach
  • Skill-building: Many evidence-based therapies involve practicing skills or completing exercises between sessions
  • Wrap-up: Setting intentions for the coming week and scheduling the next appointment

Your Role Outside the Session

A significant part of therapeutic progress happens between sessions. Your therapist may ask you to complete thought journals or mood tracking exercises, practice new coping skills in real-world situations, read specific materials, or reflect on particular questions. This is not busywork. Research shows that clients who engage with between-session work consistently show better outcomes than those who limit their effort to the therapy room.

What About Couples, Family, or Child Therapy?

The structure of therapy shifts depending on the type of service. Couples counseling often begins with joint sessions and may include individual check-ins to understand each partner’s perspective privately. Family therapy may involve different combinations of family members in different sessions. Child and adolescent counseling integrates parent involvement and uses developmentally appropriate approaches tailored to your child’s age and needs.

What to Ask

  • “What will a typical session look like for me?”
  • “Will I have homework or exercises to do between sessions?”
  • “How structured versus open-ended are your sessions?”
  • “Do you involve family members in any part of the treatment?”
  • “How do you prefer clients to communicate between sessions if something urgent comes up?”

Question 5: What Are the Costs, Do You Accept My Insurance, and What Happens If I Cannot Afford Treatment?

Cost is one of the most significant barriers to mental health care in the United States and one of the most common reasons people delay or abandon therapy. Asking about finances directly is not awkward. It is practical, responsible, and necessary.

Why This Question Matters

As one mental health resource notes, if a therapist cannot discuss finances openly with you, that itself is worth paying attention to. A willingness to have a clear, honest conversation about fees is a meaningful indicator of their communication style and commitment to your access to care.

Financial concerns are also a significant driver of therapy dropout. Research shows that clients facing higher out-of-pocket costs are more likely to discontinue therapy prematurely. Addressing this upfront can prevent a crisis mid-treatment.

Understanding Your Options

Here is what to discuss and clarify before your first paid appointment:

  • Insurance: Ask whether the therapist is in-network with your insurance plan. In-network providers typically mean lower out-of-pocket costs, usually just a copay. If the therapist is out-of-network, ask whether they can provide a “superbill,” a detailed receipt you can submit to your insurance for partial reimbursement.
  • Sliding Scale Fees: Many therapists, including those at ILCS, offer sliding scale fees based on income, ensuring that cost is not a barrier to receiving care.
  • Medicaid and SoonerCare: If you are enrolled in Title XIX Medicaid or SoonerCare, ILCS provides services at no cost to you. This is one of our most important commitments to the communities we serve across Oklahoma.
  • Telehealth Options: ILCS offers telehealth services, which can reduce the indirect costs of therapy such as travel time, gas, and childcare, particularly important for those in rural communities or with demanding schedules.

What to Ask

  • “Do you accept my insurance? Are you in-network or out-of-network?”
  • “What is your standard session fee, and do you offer sliding scale pricing?”
  • “Do you accept Medicaid or SoonerCare?”
  • “What is your cancellation policy? Is there a fee for missed appointments?”
  • “Do you offer telehealth sessions?”

At ILCS, we accept most major insurance plans, offer sliding scale fees based on income, and provide free services for SoonerCare and Title XIX Medicaid recipients. We also offer evening and weekend appointments to accommodate busy schedules. To learn more about your options, call us at (918) 960-7852 today.

Bonus Consideration: Is This the Right Therapist for Me?

Beyond the five core questions, there is one more factor worth discussing openly with any potential therapist: cultural and personal fit.

As Psychology Today notes, it is important to make sure your therapist fully affirms your ethnicity, race, sexual orientation, gender identity, age group, faith, or any other quality central to your sense of self. A therapist who cannot affirm who you are is not the right fit for you, regardless of their qualifications.

You might ask:

  • “How do you approach issues of culture, identity, and faith in your work?”
  • “Have you worked with clients from backgrounds similar to mine?”
  • “What are your strengths as a therapist, and what areas do you refer out?”

Asking about strengths and limitations is a sign of a mature therapist. The willingness to acknowledge what they do not specialize in reflects both integrity and a commitment to your wellbeing.

What to Expect at ILCS: How We Support New Clients

At Improving Lives Counseling Services, we understand that beginning therapy can feel intimidating. Our therapists are trained to make the intake process as welcoming and transparent as possible.

When you reach out to ILCS, you can expect:

  • A warm, judgment-free intake process
  • Clear discussion of your concerns, goals, and treatment options from the first conversation
  • Transparency about credentials, approaches, and expectations
  • Flexibility with scheduling, including evening and weekend appointments
  • Telehealth options for clients who cannot attend in person

We serve clients across Tulsa, Broken Arrow, Oklahoma City, Tahlequah, Pryor, Stillwater, and throughout Oklahoma through both in-person and virtual care. Our services include:

Ready to take the first step? Call us at (918) 960-7852 to speak with our intake team. We are here to answer your questions, including the ones in this article.

Practical Tips for Making the Most of a Therapy Consultation

1.Before the consultation:

  • Write down your main concerns and what you hope to get from therapy
  • Note your insurance information so you can ask about coverage
  • List any past therapy experiences, both positive and negative

2.During the consultation:

  • Ask the most important questions
  • Pay attention to how the therapist responds, as their communication style tells you a lot
  • Notice whether you feel heard and respected, not just processed

3.After the consultation:

  • Reflect on whether the conversation felt collaborative or one-sided
  • Consider whether the therapist’s approach and availability align with your needs
  • Remember that it is okay to speak with more than one therapist before deciding

Trust your instincts. Research consistently shows that the therapeutic relationship is one of the strongest predictors of successful outcomes. If a consultation leaves you feeling uncertain or unheard, it is reasonable and wise to explore other options.

What If Therapy Does Not Seem to Be Working?

Sometimes, even with the best intentions and a good initial match, therapy plateaus. That is not necessarily a reason to quit, but it is a signal to communicate.

If you feel stuck, consider:

  • Speaking up in session: Tell your therapist honestly that you do not feel progress is happening. This conversation itself can be therapeutically valuable.
  • Requesting a different approach: Therapists who practice multiple modalities can adjust their techniques if one approach is not resonating.
  • Seeking a second opinion: If you have been in therapy for several months and see no change, consulting with another provider is entirely appropriate.
  • Reassessing your commitment outside the session: Sometimes the gap in progress comes from not completing between-session work, or from external factors that need to change.

Psychology Today recommends asking your therapist to periodically check in with you about progress, so there is always an open channel to reassess direction.

Frequently Asked Questions

Author